Wisconsin Home Inspector - 4-Square Home Inspections, LLC

Thanks, you were very helpful. Loved how clear the report was laid out on e-mail--Tanya K. / Satisfied client and 1st time home buyer / Sheboygan, WI
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home Help! Solutions Where's that Rotten Egg Smell Coming From?

Where's that Rotten Egg Smell Coming From?

User Rating: / 8
PoorBest 

The incidence of "rotten egg" sulfur odors and often the resulting black water in hot and cold water lines is due to the reaction of sulfates and microorganisms in water. This can occur in the well directly, or in the household plumbing both hot and cold water pipes, or in only the water heater and hot water lines.

Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfur Bacteria in Well Water

Hydrogen sulfide gas (H2S) can occur in well water, and gives the water a characteristic "rotten egg" taste or odor. This information is provided to help explain the cause of the problem and to give the reader some solutions to reduce or eliminate the problem.

What are the sources of hydrogen sulfide in well water and the water distribution system?

Hydrogen sulfide gas can result from a number of different sources.  It can occur naturally in groundwater.  It can be produced by certain "sulfur bacteria" in the groundwater, in the well, or in the water distribution system.  It can be produced also by sulfur bacteria or chemical reactions inside water heaters.  In rare instances, it can result from pollution. The source of the gas is important when considering treatment options.

Are sulfur bacteria or hydrogen sulfide harmful?

In most cases, the rotten egg smell does not relate to the sanitary quality of the water.  However, in rare instances the gas may result from sewage or other pollution.  It is a good idea to have the well tested for the standard sanitary tests of coliform bacteria and nitrate.  Sulfur bacteria are not harmful, but hydrogen sulfide gas in the air can be hazardous at high levels. It is important to take steps to remove the gas from the water, or vent the gas to the atmosphere so that it will not collect in low-lying spaces, such as well pits, basements, or enclosed spaces, such as well houses.  Only qualified people who have received special training and use proper safety procedures should enter a well pit or other enclosed space where hydrogen sulfide gas may be present.

Are there other problems associated with sulfur bacteria or hydrogen sulfide?

Yes.  Sulfur bacteria produce a slime and can promote the growth of other bacteria, such as iron bacteria.  The slime can clog wells, plumbing, and irrigation systems. Bacterial slime may be white, grey, black or reddish brown if associated with iron bacteria.  Hydrogen sulfide gas in water can cause black stains on silverware and plumbing fixtures. It can also corrode pipes and other metal components of the water distribution system.

What causes hydrogen sulfide gas to form in groundwater?

Decay of organic matter such as vegetation, or chemical reactions with some sulfur-containing minerals in the soil and rock, may naturally create hydrogen sulfide in gas in groundwater. As groundwater moves through soil and rock formations containing minerals of sulfate, some of these minerals dissolve in the water. A unique group of bacteria, called "sulfur bacteria" or "sulfate-reducing bacteria" can change sulfate and other sulfur containing compounds, including natural organic materials, to hydrogen sulfide gas.

How can I find the source of a hydrogen sulfide problem, and what can I do to eliminate it?

The odor of hydrogen sulfide gas can be detected in water at a very low level.  Smell the water coming out of the hot and cold water faucets. Determine which faucets have the odor. The "rotten egg" smell will often be more noticeable from the hot water because more of the gas is vaporized. Your sense of smell becomes dulled quickly, so the best time to check is after you have been away from your home for a few hours. You can also have the water tested for hydrogen sulfide, sulfate, sulfur bacteria, and iron bacteria at an environmental testing laboratory. The cost of testing for hydrogen sulfide ranges from $20 to $50 depending on the type of test.

The smell is only from the hot water faucet the problem is likely to be in the water heater.

If the smell is in both the hot and cold faucets, but only from the water treated by a water softener and not in the untreated water the problem is likely to be sulfur bacteria in the water softener. If the smell is strong when the water in both the hot and cold faucets is first turned on, and it diminishes or goes away after the water has run, or if the smell varies through time the problems is likely to be sulfur bacteria in the well or distribution system. If the smell is strong when the water in both the hot and cold faucets is first turned on and is more or less constant and persists with use the problem is likely to be hydrogen sulfide gas in the groundwater.

What can I do about a problem water heater?

Unless you are very familiar with the operation and maintenance of the water heater, you should contact a water system professional, such as a plumber, to do the work. Precautions must be made to make sure the water heater is turned off so the elements or the burner will not turn on during any of these procedures. Also, the water is very hot and precautions must be made not to burn yourself or others that may be there observing or helping!

  1. Disinfect and flush the water heater with a chlorine bleach solution.  Chlorination can kill sulfur bacteria, if done properly.  If all bacteria are not destroyed by chlorination, the problem may return within a few weeks. Add one cup bleach for every 5 gallons of water the water heater holds. For example, a typical 40 gallon water heater would require 8 cups of bleach.
  2. Increase the water heater temperature to 160 degrees Fahrenheit (71 degrees Celsius) for several hours. This will destroy the sulfur bacteria.  Flushing to remove the dead bacteria after treatment should control the odor problem.
    • CAUTION: Increasing the water heater temperature can be dangerous. Before proceeding, consult with the manufacturer or dealer regarding an operable pressure relief valve, and for other recommendations. Be sure to lower the thermostat setting and make certain the water temperature is reduced following treatment to prevent injury from scalding hot water and to avoid high energy costs.
  3. Replace or remove the magnesium anode. Many water heaters have a magnesium anode, which is attached to a plug located on top of the water heater. It can be removed by turning off the water, releasing the pressure from the water heater, and unscrewing the plug. Be sure to plug the hole. Removal of the anode, however, may significantly decrease the life of the water heater. You may wish to consult with a reputable water heater dealer to determine if a replacement anode made of a different material, such as aluminum or zinc, can be installed. A replacement anode may provide corrosion protection without contributing to the production of hydrogen sulfide gas.

What if sulfur bacteria are present in the well, the water distribution system, or the water softener?

Have the well and distribution system disinfected by flushing with a strong chlorine solution (shock chlorination). Sulfur bacteria can be difficult to remove once established in a well. Physical scrubbing of the well casing, use of special treatment chemicals, and agitation of the water may be necessary prior to chlorination to remove the bacteria, particularly if they are associated with another type of bacteria known as "iron bacteria". Contact a licensed well contractor or a well specialist for details. No attempt should be made by the home owner to attempt such type of disinfection. Wells can be contaminated very easily and this type of work must be performed by a licensed professional.If the bacteria are in water treatment devices, such as a water softener, contact the manufacturer, the installer on the procedure for disinfecting the treatment devices.What if hydrogen sulfide gas is in the groundwater?The problem may only be eliminated by drilling a well into different formation capable of producing water that is free of hydrogen sulfide gas or connecting to an alternate water source, if available.

However, there are several options available for treatment of water with hydrogen sulfide gas.

  • Install an activated carbon filter. This option is only effective for low hydrogen sulfide levels, usually less than 1 milligram per liter (mg/L). The gas is trapped by the carbon filter is saturated.  Since the carbon filter can remove substances in addition to hydrogen sulfide gas, it is difficult to predict its service life. Some large carbon filters have been known to last for years, while some small filters may last for only weeks or even days.
  • Install an oxidizing filter, such as a "manganese greensand" filter. This option is effective for hydrogen sulfide levels up to about 6 mg/L. Manganese greensand filters are often used to treat iron problems in water. The device consists of manganese greensand media, which is sand coated with manganese dioxide. The hydrogen sulfide gas in the water is changed to tiny particles of sulfur as it passes through the filter. The filter must be periodically regenerated, using potassium permanganate, before the capacity of the greensand is exhausted.
  • Install an oxidation-filtration system. This option is effective for hydrogen sulfide levels up to and exceeding 6 mg/L. These systems utilize a chemical feed pump to inject an oxidizing chemical, such as chlorine, into the water supply line prior to a storage or mixing tank. When sufficient contact time is allowed, the oxidizing chemical changes the hydrogen sulfide to sulfur, which is then removed by a particulate filter, such as a manganese greensand filter. Excess chlorine can be removed by activated carbon filtration.
 

Greg Liebig

Greg Liebig, CIAQT Certified Home Inspector B.S. Degree in Mechanical Engineering WI License #1955-106

Call (920)451-4646 Fax (920) 785-4146

We're available Daily from 8 am to 9 pm.

24-7 via email or text messaging @ 920-254-9263.

Best Home Inspection 2011Voted the Best Home Inspection Company in Sheboygan County for 2011-13!

Get Flood Stop

Flood Stop

Wisconsin Real Estate News

State Real Estate Headlines